Living Alone Together
If there is one word in all this AI discourse that bothers me, it’s “taste.” It’s a word and a qualification that is as hard to define as the very reason my kid listens to one type of music and why I’m more likely to be right.
When they invented playlists, they never thought about pollution. Those scrappy engineers and lauded visionaries in a land far, far away never thought that someone would open a music player and experience musical infestation. But this is what happens on a regular basis in modern homes like mine. My playlists, my favourites and my recommendations are all infested. They’re crawling with unmentionable sounds that just the thumbnail of creates an unsettling amount of psychological discomfort.
There are now many devices and applications that hold our playlists and preferences in their precious, little hands and the new Apple HomeView is one of them. Imagine an iPad with a speaker that comes with facial recognition. You dazzle the device with your visage and then you get your profile and with it your digital you is switched on and no more AI-bedraggled quasi-Brazilian phonk in your playlists. All your taste is comfortably there inside the screen.
The immediate problem is solved but it still feels like it’s missing something. Remember docks? That physical link from the kid’s phone with the cracked screen and the weird dangling things on their case? That bit of that person is now connected to the music machine. We already have menus for all of this, but they’re buried and too fiddly and switching profiles requires the patience of a monk. Facial recognition removes the tedium sure, but leaves the experience sterile somehow.
But maybe this separation and sterility isn’t the solution. Shouldn’t it all work together somehow? We live in the same cube of concrete, plaster, various clouds, subscriptions and radio frequencies with no consensus and even less sympathy. We live together and the devices have switching but not a together. When two people watch a film, whose profile should get the viewing history? What is for everyone, what stays private and what can someone take with them? Recognising someone is different from understanding the dynamics between many, and this is something we need a lot more design work around than just better switching of profiles.